The Transition Metals: A Survey — Question 2

Section 21-1 · Chemistry pages 3449–3450

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Remove electrons in the correct order for iron ions

Neutral Fe has configuration [Ar]3d64s2[Ar]3d^64s^2. In forming the common positive ions, remove 4s electrons before 3d electrons.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Write configurations for Fe2+Fe^{2+} and Fe3+Fe^{3+} and count their total electrons using Z = 26.

  2. Explain why an orbital filling mnemonic for neutral atoms is not a universal rule for the order of electron removal.

Question 2 - Solution

Remove electrons in the correct order for iron ions

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Fe2+Fe^{2+} is [Ar]3d6[Ar]3d^6 with 24 electrons; Fe3+Fe^{3+} is [Ar]3d5[Ar]3d^5 with 23. Both 4s electrons are removed first, followed by one 3d electron for the trivalent ion.

(b) Analysis

Orbital energies depend on occupancy and the nuclear and electronic environment. The ordering relevant to building a neutral-atom configuration does not remain fixed while an atom is ionized. Electron-count conservation is a separate check on any proposed configuration.

Check and interpretation

The charge determines total electron loss; the supplied removal order determines which orbitals lose them.