The Transition Metals: A Survey — Question 5

Section 21-1 · Chemistry pages 3455–3456

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Explain a small radius change between heavier congeners

Illustrative metallic radii are Ti 147 pm, Zr 160 pm and Hf 159 pm. Zr and Hf occupy corresponding positions in the second and third transition series; the intervening lanthanides fill 4f orbitals.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the Ti-to-Zr and Zr-to-Hf radius changes and assess a simple always-increases-down-a-group claim.

  2. Explain qualitatively how imperfect shielding by 4f electrons can contribute to the small Zr-Hf difference, and why the radius definition matters.

Question 5 - Solution

Explain a small radius change between heavier congeners

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The changes are +13 pm and -1 pm. The supplied values do not support a strict monotonic increase: the heavier two are nearly the same size.

(b) Analysis

Across lanthanide filling, added nuclear charge is not completely shielded by 4f electrons, contracting outer electron distributions. This lanthanide contraction helps offset the expected size increase. Metallic, ionic and covalent radii refer to different environments and must not be mixed as if they were identical observables.

Check and interpretation

The small difference is interpreted within the supplied illustrative dataset, not as exact universal radii.