Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Critique a color rule using a d-zero ion
A student claims that every colored transition-metal compound must contain a partially filled d subshell. A supplied example is strongly colored permanganate, ; manganese is in group 7 and oxygen is -2.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find Mn oxidation state and formal d count, then test the claim.
Explain how a transition involving electron density transfer between ligand and metal can permit color even when an ordinary occupied-d to empty-d transition is unavailable.
Question 7 - Solution
Critique a color rule using a d-zero ion
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Mn satisfies , so it is +7 and formally . The example therefore contradicts the proposed universal rule.
(b) Analysis
Visible absorption can arise from charge-transfer transitions involving ligand-based occupied orbitals and metal-containing acceptor orbitals. A partly filled d subshell is important for many d-d spectra but is not a requirement for every possible electronic absorption mechanism.
Check and interpretation
Color is evidence of absorption, not by itself a unique assignment of a d configuration.