Isomerism — Question 2

Section 21-4 · Chemistry pages 3509–3510

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Explain why a tetrahedral MA2B2 complex has one arrangement

An ideal tetrahedral metal complex contains two identical A ligands and two identical B ligands, all monodentate. All pairs of distinct vertices have the same ligand-metal-ligand angle.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Determine whether separate cis and trans forms exist in this ideal tetrahedral model.

  2. Explain why placing two A labels on different edges in a drawing does not necessarily generate new isomers.

Question 2 - Solution

Explain why a tetrahedral MA2B2 complex has one arrangement

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

There is only one geometric arrangement for tetrahedral MA2B2MA_2B_2. There are no opposite 180-degree vertex pairs to define the square-planar trans relation; all distinct pairs subtend about 109.5 degrees.

(b) Analysis

Tetrahedral rotations map any edge to any other edge. Choosing the A pair on a different drawn edge can therefore give the same labeled structure in a new orientation. Isomer counting must identify such rotationally equivalent drawings.

Check and interpretation

The answer depends on the geometry, not just the formula MA2B2.