Isomerism — Question 8

Section 21-4 · Chemistry pages 3521–3522

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Test a chelate mirror relationship using labeled donor sites

Three identical symmetric bidentate ligands join adjacent sites of an octahedron. In A the joined pairs are (+x,+y)(+x,+y), (−x,+z)(-x,+z), (−y,−z)(-y,-z). In B they are (+x,−y)(+x,-y), (−x,+z)(-x,+z), (+y,−z)(+y,-z). Ignore individual chelate-ring conformations.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Show that reflection y↦−yy\mapsto-y maps A into B, and state the additional criterion needed to call them enantiomers.

  2. For these pairing patterns no proper octahedral rotation maps A to B, even allowing exchange of the identical ligands. Classify the pair and explain why a ligand need not itself be chiral for the complex to be chiral.

Question 8 - Solution

Test a chelate mirror relationship using labeled donor sites

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The reflection swaps +y and -y while leaving x and z sites unchanged, transforming each listed A pair into the corresponding B pair. To establish enantiomers, the mirror-related structures must also be nonsuperposable by a proper rotation.

(b) Analysis

Given the absence of a superposing rotation, A and B are enantiomers. The handed arrangement of the three chelate connections creates chirality at the level of the full complex even if each isolated ligand is achiral. A reflection changes handedness; a rigid rotation does not.

Check and interpretation

Identical ligands may be permuted when testing superposition; the chelate connections must remain intact.