Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Count square-planar MABCD structures without double counting
An ideal square-planar complex has four different monodentate ligands A, B, C and D. Ignore ligand internal stereochemistry. Whole-molecule rotations, including turning the plane over in three dimensions, do not create new structures.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Count distinct arrangements by choosing the ligand trans to A, and list the trans-pair combinations.
Explain why counting all placements on four drawn positions overcounts the isomers.
Question 10 - Solution
Count square-planar MABCD structures without double counting
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
A can be trans to B, C or D. The remaining two ligands are then trans to each other, giving three classes: AB/CD, AC/BD and AD/BC.
(b) Analysis
The 24 labeled placements include four in-plane rotations and a factor of two from viewing the same planar molecule from the opposite side. Dividing by these eight equivalent views gives . Trans-pair identity provides a simpler rotationally invariant count.
Check and interpretation
The argument assumes an ideal planar framework and ignores stereochemistry inside the ligands.