Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Use the 18-electron count as a heuristic rather than a law
For ionic electron counting, add the formal d-electron count to two electrons per neutral monodentate sigma donor. Compare and ; group numbers are Co = 9 and Ni = 10.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate the formal metal-centered valence-electron count for each.
Explain why the second count does not by itself prove that the aqua complex is impossible or that the Pauli principle is violated.
Question 7 - Solution
Use the 18-electron count as a heuristic rather than a law
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Co(III) is d6 and receives a formal 12-electron ligand contribution, totaling 18. Ni(II) is d8 and receives 12, totaling 20.
(b) Analysis
The 18-electron rule is most useful for particular bonding regimes, especially many low-spin organometallic complexes; it is not universal for all coordination ions. This bookkeeping sum is not a claim that twenty electrons occupy nine identical low-energy atomic orbitals. Antibonding and delocalized molecular states matter in fuller descriptions.
Check and interpretation
A formal counting heuristic must be applied within its chemical scope.