Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Locate the limitation of a metal-only redox assignment
A hypothetical neutral complex has a group-8 metal and two redox-active ligands. Description A assigns M(II) and two ligands. Description B assigns M(III), one and one radical ligand. These are alternative formal electron-localization descriptions of the same total composition.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Check total charge and metal d count for each description, and account for the electron shifted between metal and ligand descriptions.
Explain why total charge or a simple donor-pair diagram alone cannot choose between them.
Question 9 - Solution
Locate the limitation of a metal-only redox assignment
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
A has charge and a d6 metal. B has and a d5 metal. Relative to A, one electron is assigned from the metal to one ligand in B; the complete complex electron total is unchanged.
(b) Analysis
The ambiguity concerns where electron density is assigned within a coupled metal-ligand system. Structural, spectroscopic and magnetic evidence, interpreted with an appropriate electronic model, is needed. A metal-only oxidation-state label can miss ligand participation in redox.
Check and interpretation
The two descriptions are formal models here, not automatically two separable compounds.