Bonding in Complex Ions: The Localized Electron Model — Question 10

Section 21-5 · Chemistry pages 3545–3546

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Identify what a localized geometry label cannot predict about color

Two square-planar complexes share the same traditional dsp2 label but have supplied absorption bands at 520 nm and 650 nm. For this comparison use E=hc/λE=hc/\lambda and hc=1240hc=1240 eV nm.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the photon energies and their difference.

  2. Explain why a common localized geometry label does not require identical spectra and what extra kind of information a quantitative model needs.

Question 10 - Solution

Identify what a localized geometry label cannot predict about color

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The band energies are 1240/520=2.38461240/520=2.3846 eV and 1240/650=1.90771240/650=1.9077 eV, differing by 0.4769 eV. The shorter-wavelength band has higher energy.

(b) Analysis

The label states a geometric orbital construction but supplies no numerical separations between actual electronic states. Ligand identity, metal-ligand covalency, orbital splitting and possible charge-transfer states affect spectra. A quantitative model must supply energy levels and allowed transitions.

Check and interpretation

A measured absorption wavelength cannot be obtained merely by counting hybrid orbitals.