The Crystal Field Model — Question 3

Section 21-6 · Chemistry pages 3551–3552

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Decide a d4 spin state by comparing splitting and pairing

For an octahedral d4 ion, take orbital energies t2g=−0.4Δot_{2g}=-0.4\Delta_o and eg=+0.6Δoe_g=+0.6\Delta_o. Each doubly occupied orbital costs an additional pairing energy P. Compare Δo=180\Delta_o=180 and 260 kJ/mol, using P = 220 kJ/mol in both cases.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Write high-spin and low-spin occupancies and derive their energy difference, including pairing.

  2. Choose the lower-energy configuration for each Delta value and give its unpaired-electron count.

Question 3 - Solution

Decide a d4 spin state by comparing splitting and pairing

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

High spin is t2g3eg1t_{2g}^3e_g^1, with CFSE −0.6Δo-0.6\Delta_o and no pair. Low spin is t2g4t_{2g}^4, with CFSE −1.6Δo-1.6\Delta_o and one pair. Thus ELS−EHS=P−ΔoE_{LS}-E_{HS}=P-\Delta_o.

(b) Analysis

At Delta = 180 the difference is +40 kJ/mol, so high spin wins and has four unpaired electrons. At Delta = 260 it is -40 kJ/mol, so low spin wins and has two unpaired electrons. Pairing and splitting must be compared in the same units.

Check and interpretation

Counting only the lower-set occupancy would miss the cost of the additional electron pair.