The Crystal Field Model — Question 5

Section 21-6 · Chemistry pages 3555–3556

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Compare d5 stabilization and magnetism in two ligand fields

Consider octahedral d5 in the limiting high-spin and low-spin fillings. Use t2g=−0.4Δot_{2g}=-0.4\Delta_o, eg=+0.6Δoe_g=+0.6\Delta_o and a pairing cost P per electron pair.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the orbital occupancies, CFSE alone and pair counts for both limits.

  2. Give unpaired-electron counts and spin-only moments, and explain why a zero high-spin CFSE does not mean no metal-ligand bonding.

Question 5 - Solution

Compare d5 stabilization and magnetism in two ligand fields

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

High spin is t2g3eg2t_{2g}^3e_g^2, giving 3(−0.4)+2(0.6)=03(-0.4)+2(0.6)=0 times Delta and zero pairs. Low spin is t2g5t_{2g}^5, giving −2.0Δo-2.0\Delta_o and two pairs; including pairing, its relative energy is −2Δo+2P-2\Delta_o+2P.

(b) Analysis

High spin has five unpaired electrons and moment 35=5.916μB\sqrt{35}=5.916\,\mu_B; low spin has one and 3=1.732μB\sqrt3=1.732\,\mu_B. CFSE is measured relative to a d-level average and does not include all the bonding energy of the complex.

Check and interpretation

Keep CFSE alone separate from a total that also includes pairing.