Show solutionHide solution
Question 1
Count the donors around a heme iron
A simplified deoxygenated heme site has four porphyrin nitrogen donors and one histidine nitrogen donor coordinated to iron. Reversible oxygen binding adds one donor atom from one O2 molecule at the vacant axial site. The porphyrin is one tetradentate ligand; histidine and bound O2 are each monodentate in this model.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find the coordination number and number of ligand entities before and after oxygen binding.
Explain why this coordination inventory does not by itself establish the electronic structure of the oxygenated site or prove that oxygen binding is identical to irreversible iron oxidation.
Question 1 - Solution
Count the donors around a heme iron
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Before binding, the coordination number is , from two ligand entities. After binding, it is , from three entities. One O2 molecule supplies one directly coordinated donor atom in the stipulated end-on model.
(b) Analysis
Counting donor atoms describes connectivity, not charge distribution. The iron-oxygen bond can have substantial covalent and charge-transfer character, so formal electron assignments need an electronic model or evidence. Reversible oxygen coordination and oxidation to an inactive ferric site are distinct processes; the coordination count alone does not identify either electronic state.
Check and interpretation
Four donor atoms within a single macrocycle must not be counted as four separate ligands.