Metallurgy and Iron and Steel Production — Question 6

Section 21-8 · Chemistry pages 3597–3598

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Compare oxide stability on an equal oxygen basis

At one temperature, hypothetical standard formation Gibbs energies are -200 kJ per mole of MO for M + one-half O2 to MO, and -900 kJ per mole of Al2O3 for 2Al + three-halves O2 to Al2O3. All listed solids have unit activity.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Balance aluminum reduction of MO and calculate DeltaG for the balanced reaction.

  2. Normalize both oxide formation energies per mole O2 and explain the conclusion and one reason favorable DeltaG does not ensure a fast reaction.

Question 6 - Solution

Compare oxide stability on an equal oxygen basis

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

3MO+2Al→3M+Al2O33\mathrm{MO}+2\mathrm{Al}\to3\mathrm{M}+\mathrm{Al_2O_3}. Reversing three MO formations costs +600 kJ and forming Al2O3 releases 900 kJ, so net ΔG∘=−300\Delta G^\circ=-300 kJ per reaction as written.

(b) Analysis

MO formation is -400 kJ per mole O2; Al2O3 formation is -600 kJ per mole O2. Aluminum has the greater oxygen affinity in this supplied standard-state comparison, consistent with favorable reduction. Activation barriers, solid-state diffusion or protective surface films may still limit the rate; this is not a practical process specification.

Check and interpretation

Comparing -200 and -900 directly without matching oxygen inventories would be misleading.