Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Separate alloy composition from processing history
Two specimens of the same carbon steel have identical chemical analyses. A is cooled slowly from its austenitic region; B is rapidly quenched from that region under conditions that produce a much larger fraction of martensite. For this comparison, assume martensite is harder and less ductile than the slowly formed microstructure.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Predict relative hardness and ductility and explain why identical bulk carbon content does not force identical properties.
Design a controlled comparison to test the effect of tempering specimen B, and distinguish a structural change from removal of carbon atoms from the specimen.
Question 10 - Solution
Separate alloy composition from processing history
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Under the stated assumptions, B is harder and less ductile than A. Cooling rate affects atomic rearrangement, phase formation and how carbon is distributed or trapped, so the same overall composition can produce different microstructures and properties.
(b) Analysis
Divide comparable quenched samples, temper one at a specified time and temperature and retain the other as a control. Compare hardness, ductility and microstructure with matched testing, while preventing surface decarburization. Tempering can redistribute carbon and change phases without removing carbon from the bulk; verify composition if loss is possible. A property change alone does not establish a change in total carbon content.
Check and interpretation
Processing history is an independent variable; the question supplies the needed phase-property relation.