Alkanes: Saturated Hydrocarbons — Question 10

Section 22-1 · Chemistry pages 3625–3626

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Compare combustion emissions per unit energy

For an idealized complete-combustion comparison, methane supplies 55.0 kJ/g and propane supplies 50.0 kJ/g of useful energy. Use C = 12.00, H = 1.00 and O = 16.00 g/mol. Consider only CO2 formed by combustion, excluding upstream processes.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate grams of CO2 per megajoule of useful energy for each fuel.

  2. Explain why equal fuel masses and equal delivered energies are different comparison bases.

Question 10 - Solution

Compare combustion emissions per unit energy

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

CH4 produces one CO2: 44/16=2.7544/16=2.75 g CO2 per gram fuel. Its intensity is (2.75/55.0)(1000)=50.0(2.75/55.0)(1000)=50.0 g/MJ. C3H8 produces three CO2: 132/44=3.00132/44=3.00 g/g. Its intensity is (3.00/50.0)(1000)=60.0(3.00/50.0)(1000)=60.0 g/MJ.

(b) Analysis

One gram of each fuel delivers a different amount of useful energy. Comparing on an energy basis divides the mass emission factor by the useful energy per mass. Methane gives the smaller combustion-only value for these stipulated inputs; this limited calculation is not a complete life-cycle comparison.

Check and interpretation

Energy units cancel to g/kJ before multiplication by 1000 kJ/MJ.