Show solutionHide solution
Question 1
Interpret equivalent bonds without invoking molecular switching
A benzene sample has six equal C-C bond lengths, supplied as 139 pm. Representative localized C-C and C=C distances are 154 and 134 pm. Two Kekule drawings put alternating double bonds in different positions.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Explain why neither localized drawing alone captures the observed bond pattern and why resonance is not rapid switching between two molecules.
Assess whether the observed distance must equal the arithmetic mean of the supplied single- and double-bond lengths.
Question 1 - Solution
Interpret equivalent bonds without invoking molecular switching
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Each localized drawing assigns alternating bond types, whereas all six observed bonds are equivalent. The resonance drawings describe contributions to one delocalized electronic structure at the same nuclear arrangement. They are not separate molecules interconverting in time.
(b) Analysis
The arithmetic mean is pm, not 139 pm. Bond lengths do not generally interpolate linearly with a formal averaged bond order. Equivalent intermediate distances support delocalization but do not require an arithmetic average of unrelated reference bonds.
Check and interpretation
Resonance changes electron placement in a drawing, not the connectivity or positions of the carbon nuclei.