Atomic Masses — Question 4

Section 3-1 · Chemistry pages 353–354

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Combine populations rather than averaging averages blindly

Sample P contains 100 atoms with mean mass 10.20 u; sample Q contains 300 atoms with mean mass 10.80 u. Treat counts and means as exact model data.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the combined mean.

  2. Why is 10.50 u incorrect?

  3. What mean results if equal atom counts are mixed instead?

Question 4 - Solution

Combine populations rather than averaging averages blindly

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Total mass is 100(10.20)+300(10.80)=4260100(10.20)+300(10.80)=4260 u. Dividing by 400 gives 10.65 u.

(b) Analysis

That value weights unequal atom populations equally. Q contributes three times as many atoms.

(c) Conclusion

Equal atom counts give (10.20+10.80)/2=10.50(10.20+10.80)/2=10.50 u. Weighting is by number of atoms, not number of sample containers.

Check and interpretation

The combined mean is closer to Q, the larger population.