Precipitation Reactions — Question 10

Section 4-5 · Chemistry pages 625–626

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Check all plausible solids in a mixed-ion system

A solution contains Ba2+Ba^{2+} and Ag+Ag^+ with nitrate counterions. A reagent adds both sulfate and chloride in sufficient quantities. Assume BaSO4BaSO_4 and AgCl precipitate, barium chloride remains soluble, and under these conditions silver sulfate precipitation is negligible.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify the two solids expected.

  2. Why is a single total collected mass insufficient to determine each original cation amount?

Question 10 - Solution

Check all plausible solids in a mixed-ion system

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Barium forms BaSO4(s)BaSO_4(s) and silver forms AgCl(s) under the supplied selectivity assumptions. Nitrate remains in solution.

(b) Analysis

Total solid mass is the sum of two unknown contributions. One mass measurement gives only one equation for two cation amounts; separate the products or obtain another independent measurement.

Check and interpretation

A mixed precipitate can undermine a single-species gravimetric interpretation.