Effusion and Diffusion — Question 5

Section 5-7 · Chemistry pages 855–856

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Account for temperature at fixed pressure

For the same gas and aperture, a dilute effusion model gives number flux J=(N/V)u¯/4J=(N/V)\overline u/4, with N/V∝P/TN/V\propto P/T and u¯∝T\overline u\propto\sqrt T. Compare 300 K and 600 K at the same maintained pressure.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Derive the temperature dependence of flux at fixed P and find the ratio.

  2. Why is faster molecular motion alone an incomplete explanation?

Question 5 - Solution

Account for temperature at fixed pressure

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

J∝(P/T)T=P/TJ\propto(P/T)\sqrt T=P/\sqrt T. Thus J600/J300=300/600=1/2=0.707J_{600}/J_{300}=\sqrt{300/600}=1/\sqrt2=0.707.

(b) Analysis

Heating increases speed but reduces number density at fixed P. The density decrease wins in the product. At fixed number density instead, flux would grow as T\sqrt T.

Check and interpretation

Graham comparisons at common temperature must not be extended to changing conditions without the density factor.