The Nature of Energy — Question 4

Section 6-1 · Chemistry pages 913–914

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Compare two paths between the same states

Two paths take the same closed system from state A to state B. Path I has q = +800 J and w = -300 J. Path II has w = -120 J.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the heat for path II.

  2. Which of q, w and ΔU\Delta U must agree between paths?

Question 4 - Solution

Compare two paths between the same states

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Path I gives ΔU=800−300=500\Delta U=800-300=500 J. The same endpoints require qII=ΔU−wII=500−(−120)=620q_{\mathrm{II}}=\Delta U-w_{\mathrm{II}}=500-(-120)=620 J.

(b) Analysis

Only ΔU\Delta U must agree because internal energy is a state function. Heat and work describe transfers along a path; their sum agrees even when they individually differ.

Check and interpretation

The endpoint condition includes composition, temperature and other variables needed to define the state.