Enthalpy and Calorimetry — Question 10

Section 6-2 · Chemistry pages 945–946

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Decide whether two calorimetric values are distinguishable

A reaction of exactly 0.0200 mol produces a temperature rise bounded by [1.90,2.10] K. Total heat capacity is independently bounded by [390,410] J/K. Assume no losses and exothermic reaction.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Bound the magnitude of the molar reaction enthalpy.

  2. Can these bounds distinguish candidate values -38.0 and -42.0 kJ/mol?

Question 10 - Solution

Decide whether two calorimetric values are distinguishable

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The smallest magnitude is 390(1.90)/(0.0200⋅1000)=37.05390(1.90)/(0.0200\cdot1000)=37.05 kJ/mol. The largest is 410(2.10)/(0.0200⋅1000)=43.05410(2.10)/(0.0200\cdot1000)=43.05 kJ/mol. Signed values lie in [−43.05,−37.05][-43.05,-37.05] kJ/mol.

(b) Analysis

No. Both candidate values lie within the allowed interval. Better control of heat capacity and temperature rise, and checks on systematic heat loss, would be needed to discriminate.

Check and interpretation

These are worst-case bounds under the model, not a statistical confidence interval.