Hess’s Law — Question 5

Section 6-3 · Chemistry pages 955–956

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Distinguish a catalytic route from changed endpoints

For a hypothetical isomerization at fixed temperature, the direct enthalpy change A→BA\to B is -50 kJ/mol. A catalytic route passes through I, with A→IA\to I equal to +20 kJ/mol. Catalyst is regenerated and both routes have identical overall initial and final states.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the enthalpy of I→BI\to B.

  2. Could a catalyst change the overall enthalpy to -80 kJ/mol while leaving those endpoints unchanged?

Question 5 - Solution

Distinguish a catalytic route from changed endpoints

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The two steps must sum to −50-50 kJ/mol. Thus ΔHI→B=−50−20=−70\Delta H_{I\to B}=-50-20=-70 kJ/mol.

(b) Analysis

No. A catalyst can change the route and reaction rate, but overall enthalpy is fixed by the same endpoints. A claimed -80 kJ/mol would imply different states, an omitted process or an error.

Check and interpretation

Intermediate enthalpy is not an activation barrier. No reaction-rate conclusion follows from these step enthalpies alone.