Hess’s Law — Question 8

Section 6-3 · Chemistry pages 961–962

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Carry measurement bounds through subtraction

Two hypothetical paths give A→C=−100±2A\to C=-100\pm2 kJ and B→C=−40±1B\to C=-40\pm1 kJ for the same amount and states. Treat the uncertainties as independent hard bounds.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the central enthalpy for A→BA\to B.

  2. Find its allowed interval and decide whether -64 kJ is compatible.

Question 8 - Solution

Carry measurement bounds through subtraction

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Add A to C to the reverse of B to C. The central result is −100−(−40)=−60-100-(-40)=-60 kJ.

(b) Analysis

The smallest result is −102−(−39)=−63-102-(-39)=-63 kJ; the largest is −98−(−41)=−57-98-(-41)=-57 kJ. Thus the interval is [−63,−57][-63,-57] kJ, and -64 kJ is outside it.

Check and interpretation

For hard bounds in a difference, extreme errors can add. A statistical standard uncertainty would require a different rule.