Standard Enthalpies of Formation — Question 10

Section 6-4 · Chemistry pages 985–986

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Compare isomer enthalpies without claiming reaction rates

Two hypothetical gaseous isomers X and Y have the same molecular formula. At 298 K their formation enthalpies are -50.0 and -70.0 kJ/mol, respectively. Their complete combustion gives identical amounts and phases of products.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the enthalpy for X to Y and compare their molar combustion enthalpies.

  2. Can these data establish how quickly X converts to Y, or the equilibrium composition?

Question 10 - Solution

Compare isomer enthalpies without claiming reaction rates

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

ΔHX→Y∘=−70.0−(−50.0)=−20.0\Delta H^\circ_{X\to Y}=-70.0-(-50.0)=-20.0 kJ/mol. Let common product sum be P. Combustion values are P+50.0P+50.0 for X and P+70.0P+70.0 for Y; X combustion is 20.0 kJ/mol more negative.

(b) Analysis

No. Rates need kinetic information such as an activation barrier. Equilibrium also depends on entropy through free energy, not enthalpy alone. Y is lower in enthalpy, which is a narrower conclusion than complete thermodynamic or kinetic stability.

Check and interpretation

The same formula and combustion products ensure the comparison uses the same amount of each element.