Present Sources of Energy — Question 4

Section 6-5 · Chemistry pages 993–994

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Compare direct carbon dioxide per delivered energy

Two hypothetical plants burn pure graphite or pure methane completely. Per mole fuel, graphite releases 393.5 kJ and methane releases 890.3 kJ to the same product reference states; each forms 1 mol CO2_2. Their useful-energy efficiencies are 0.400 and 0.500, respectively. Use M(CO2_2) = 44.0 g/mol.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate direct CO2_2 in g per MJ of useful energy for each plant.

  2. State one reason these results are not complete life-cycle comparisons.

Question 4 - Solution

Compare direct carbon dioxide per delivered energy

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Graphite delivers 0.3935(0.400)=0.15740.3935(0.400)=0.1574 MJ/mol, giving 44.0/0.1574=28044.0/0.1574=280 g/MJ to three figures. Methane delivers 0.8903(0.500)=0.445150.8903(0.500)=0.44515 MJ/mol, giving 44.0/0.44515=98.844.0/0.44515=98.8 g/MJ.

(b) Analysis

The calculation counts only combustion CO2_2. Extraction, processing, transport, upstream leakage, construction and other emissions are outside its boundary. It also compares the supplied efficiencies, which are not universal plant properties.

Check and interpretation

Normalize by delivered energy, not merely by moles or kilograms of fuel.