Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Estimate energy payback without confusing it with carbon payback
A hypothetical energy installation requires 12000 kWh-equivalent to manufacture and install. It delivers 4000 kWh-equivalent per year and requires 500 kWh-equivalent per year in operating energy. All numbers use the same explicitly chosen energy-accounting basis. Assume constant output and a 20-year life; neglect end-of-life energy.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find energy payback time and net lifetime energy after all stated inputs.
Can these data alone determine carbon payback time?
Question 9 - Solution
Estimate energy payback without confusing it with carbon payback
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Annual net energy is kWh-equivalent. Payback is years. Net lifetime energy is kWh-equivalent.
(b) Analysis
No. Carbon payback also needs emissions factors for manufacturing and operation and a defined counterfactual for displaced energy. Equal energy inputs can have different emissions, so energy payback is not automatically carbon payback.
Check and interpretation
Comparing primary energy with delivered electricity without a common accounting basis could produce a misleading payback.