Show solutionHide solution
Question 3
Evaluate competing effects down a group
For two hypothetical valence distributions in one group, use the rough scale . Atom A has , ; atom B has , .
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find in this model.
Explain how a larger effective charge can coexist with a larger radius, and state a limit of the estimate.
Question 3 - Solution
Evaluate competing effects down a group
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The ratio is , about 1.69. B is larger in the model despite its stronger effective charge.
(b) Analysis
The larger principal-shell factor outweighs the increase in attraction. Down-group size trends reflect competing shell and shielding effects. A one-parameter hydrogen-like scale does not supply exact covalent or ionic radii for real multi-electron atoms.
Check and interpretation
The comparison changes n as well as effective nuclear charge; hold neither effect implicit.