Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Compare each ion with its own parent atom
Neutral sodium is , while neutral chlorine is . Consider formation of and .
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Explain qualitatively why sodium contracts strongly on losing one electron.
Explain why chlorine generally expands on gaining one electron, although its proton count is unchanged.
Question 5 - Solution
Compare each ion with its own parent atom
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
has the [Ne] configuration: removal empties the outer n = 3 shell, leaving the n = 2 shell outermost. The remaining distribution is also bound by the same eleven-proton nucleus with fewer electrons.
(b) Analysis
retains n = 3 as its outer shell but adds an electron there. Increased electron repulsion and altered shielding expand the distribution relative to the neutral parent. The comparison does not require adding or removing protons.
Check and interpretation
The qualitative parent-ion trend does not identify a unique radius independent of chemical environment.