Periodic Trends in Atomic Properties — Question 9

Section 7-12 · Chemistry pages 1263–1264

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Keep electron-affinity sign conventions explicit

For X(g)+e−→X−(g)\mathrm{X}(g)+e^-\to\mathrm{X}^{-}(g), a hypothetical molar energy change is −320-320 kJ/mol. Adding another electron to form X2−(g)\mathrm{X}^{2-}(g) requires +680+680 kJ/mol. Some tables instead define positive electron affinity as energy released.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Give the first affinity under the positive-release convention and the total change for adding two electrons.

  2. Explain why the second attachment can be unfavorable even when the first releases energy.

Question 9 - Solution

Keep electron-affinity sign conventions explicit

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The first affinity is +320 kJ/mol under the positive-release convention, while the attachment energy change is -320 kJ/mol. The two-step total is −320+680=+360-320+680=+360 kJ/mol, an energy cost.

(b) Analysis

The second incoming electron encounters an already negatively charged species. Repulsion can make gas-phase attachment endothermic. Stabilization by a surrounding ionic lattice or solvent is a separate contribution, so free-ion energetics alone does not decide whether a compound can exist.

Check and interpretation

Always specify the process and sign convention before comparing electron-affinity numbers.