Show solutionHide solution
Question 2
Separate easy electron removal from a complete rate prediction
Use rounded first gas-phase ionization energies Li = 520, Na = 496 and K = 419 kJ/mol. A student claims that these numbers alone determine exact relative rates of reaction of the metals with liquid water.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Identify the ionization trend and explain it using outer-shell structure.
Assess the rate claim and identify two additional factors that can matter.
Question 2 - Solution
Separate easy electron removal from a complete rate prediction
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The removal cost decreases Li to Na to K. Outer electrons occupy progressively larger shells and experience substantial shielding, so they are generally less tightly held despite the increasing proton number.
(b) Analysis
The numbers describe isolated gas atoms, not a complete metal–water reaction pathway. Rates also depend on surface condition and area, temperature, heat transfer, melting and the reaction mechanism. Ionization energies help interpret chemistry but cannot alone yield exact reaction-rate ratios.
Check and interpretation
A thermodynamic step cost and a kinetic rate are different quantities.