Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Combine energy terms before ranking aqueous tendencies
Use this hypothetical enthalpy model for : atomization, gas ionization, then cation hydration. For Li the three values are +161, +520 and -520 kJ/mol; for Na they are +109, +496 and -406 kJ/mol. Use the same electron reference in both cases.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate the two net enthalpy changes and compare them.
Explain why the lower gas ionization cost does not determine the net ranking, and why these enthalpies alone do not give a standard electrode potential.
Question 7 - Solution
Combine energy terms before ranking aqueous tendencies
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Li gives kJ/mol. Na gives kJ/mol. Li has the lower net cost by 38 kJ/mol in this model even though its gas ionization step is more costly.
(b) Analysis
The more negative hydration contribution for Li offsets the other differences. A complete aqueous comparison must include all relevant steps. Standard potentials involve Gibbs energy for a defined electrochemical reaction and reference, including entropy and standard-state terms; a sum of these hypothetical enthalpies is insufficient.
Check and interpretation
The model illustrates competing contributions; the numerical values are supplied educational inputs.