Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Use a spectral fingerprint without overclaiming identification
In a simplified reference set, H has detectable lines at 486 and 656 nm, while X has lines at 520 and 700 nm. A sample shows 486, 520 and 656 nm. Treat the listed positions as exact; the detector may miss weak lines.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Can H alone explain all observed lines within this reference set?
Does the absence of a 700 nm detection rule out X?
Question 9 - Solution
Use a spectral fingerprint without overclaiming identification
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
No. H accounts for 486 and 656 nm but not 520 nm. H plus X is consistent with all three observed positions under the supplied reference set.
(b) Analysis
No. A missing weak line can reflect sensitivity or excitation conditions. The presence of 520 nm supports X within this restricted set, but complete identification would require calibration, additional lines and consideration of other possible species.
Check and interpretation
This is an illustrative fingerprint problem, not an actual assignment of a new element X.