The Bohr Model — Question 1

Section 7-4 · Chemistry pages 1087–1088

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

Apply the squared dependence of an allowed radius

In the Bohr model for hydrogen, rn=a0n2r_n=a_0n^2, with a0=0.0529a_0=0.0529 nm.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find radii for n = 1 and n = 3, and their ratio.

  2. Is r = 2a0a_0 an allowed radius in this model?

Question 1 - Solution

Apply the squared dependence of an allowed radius

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

r1=0.0529r_1=0.0529 nm and r3=9a0=0.4761r_3=9a_0=0.4761 nm. The ratio is 9, not 3.

(b) Analysis

It would require n=2n=\sqrt2, not a positive integer. Thus it is not one of the model's allowed radii. The conclusion concerns this historical model, not a measurement of a sharp orbital boundary in modern theory.

Check and interpretation

Quantization restricts n; it does not allow arbitrary continuous circular radii.