Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Explain both the success and the limit of the Bohr picture
A classical accelerating electric charge radiates. A planetary picture would therefore make a circling electron lose energy continuously. Bohr instead postulated stationary allowed states and radiation only in transitions.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Explain how the postulate addresses the collapse problem within the model.
Give one predictive success and one limitation without treating postulates as a derivation from classical physics.
Question 10 - Solution
Explain both the success and the limit of the Bohr picture
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
If an allowed stationary orbit does not radiate, it does not continuously lose energy and spiral inward. Radiation is restricted to differences between allowed states. This overrides the classical prediction rather than following from it.
(b) Analysis
The model explains hydrogen-like principal energy levels and associated spectral wavelengths. It does not provide a satisfactory general account of multi-electron atoms or modern orbital probabilities. Stationary circular trajectories are superseded by quantum states.
Check and interpretation
Agreement with some spectra is evidence for quantization, not proof of literal planetary electron paths.