Show solutionHide solution
Question 4
Compare shape and energy in ideal hydrogen
In ideal hydrogen without external fields, orbital energy is eV and depends only on n. Consider 2s and 2p.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Compare their energies and angular shapes.
Can their different shapes alone be used to infer different energies in this model?
Question 4 - Solution
Compare shape and energy in ideal hydrogen
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Both have energy -3.40 eV. The 2s orbital is spherically symmetric with a radial node; a real 2p orbital has angular directionality and a nodal plane.
(b) Analysis
No. Degenerate states can have different shapes. Their energy equality follows from the stated hydrogen Hamiltonian; the same equality need not survive electron-electron interactions in larger atoms.
Check and interpretation
Equal energy does not make their wavefunctions interchangeable as spatial distributions.