Orbital Shapes and Energies — Question 9

Section 7-7 · Chemistry pages 1163–1164

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Distinguish same-shell energies in two different models

In ideal hydrogen, 3s and 3p are degenerate. In a hypothetical effective one-electron model for a larger atom, their energies are -8.00 and -5.00 eV, respectively. Treat these as the complete state-energy differences for this exercise.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the photon energy for 3p to 3s in the hypothetical model.

  2. Why would the ideal hydrogen model give no nonzero-frequency photon for that same-n pair?

Question 9 - Solution

Distinguish same-shell energies in two different models

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The photon carries −5.00−(−8.00)=3.00-5.00-(-8.00)=3.00 eV in the supplied effective model.

(b) Analysis

Ideal hydrogen energies depend only on n, so its energy difference is zero. A zero gap cannot supply a photon of nonzero frequency. Small real-hydrogen corrections are outside that approximation.

Check and interpretation

In actual multi-electron spectroscopy, differences of orbital energies alone need not equal full many-electron transition energies.