Show solutionHide solution
Question 4
Separate Pauli permission from a ground-state preference
Two candidate occupancies for two electrons in a p subshell are shown. In A both share one orbital with opposite spins; in B they occupy different orbitals with parallel spins.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Does either violate Pauli exclusion?
Can Pauli exclusion alone prove which has lower energy?
Question 4 - Solution
Separate Pauli permission from a ground-state preference
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Neither violates Pauli. A has a legal opposite-spin pair, while B uses different spatial orbitals, so the shared spin does not make all four quantum numbers identical.
(b) Analysis
No. Pauli rules out duplicate spin-orbital occupancy but does not by itself rank all legal states. Electron interactions and an energy rule such as Hund's rule are needed to select a ground-state arrangement.
Check and interpretation
Allowed and lowest-energy are different judgments.