Electron Spin and the Pauli Principle — Question 4

Section 7-8 · Chemistry pages 1173–1174

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Separate Pauli permission from a ground-state preference

Two candidate occupancies for two electrons in a p subshell are shown. In A both share one orbital with opposite spins; in B they occupy different orbitals with parallel spins.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Does either violate Pauli exclusion?

  2. Can Pauli exclusion alone prove which has lower energy?

Question 4 - Solution

Separate Pauli permission from a ground-state preference

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Neither violates Pauli. A has a legal opposite-spin pair, while B uses different spatial orbitals, so the shared spin does not make all four quantum numbers identical.

(b) Analysis

No. Pauli rules out duplicate spin-orbital occupancy but does not by itself rank all legal states. Electron interactions and an energy rule such as Hund's rule are needed to select a ground-state arrangement.

Check and interpretation

Allowed and lowest-energy are different judgments.