Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Avoid counting exchanged electron labels as new occupancies
An orbital contains two electrons in opposite spin states. A student labels them electron 1 and electron 2, then claims swapping those labels creates a second distinct orbital occupancy.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Explain why the occupancy has not changed.
What does distinguish the two occupied one-electron states?
Question 10 - Solution
Avoid counting exchanged electron labels as new occupancies
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Electrons are indistinguishable. Exchanging arbitrary labels does not create a new occupation: the same spatial orbital still contains one up-spin and one down-spin electron. The many-electron state must respect fermionic antisymmetry.
(b) Analysis
The occupied spin orbitals differ in spin projection, while their spatial part is the same. These are two occupied state labels, not permanent identities attached to individually trackable electrons.
Check and interpretation
Indistinguishability is consistent with counting two electrons; it forbids treating arbitrary name swaps as new physical occupations.