Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Design a discriminating follow-up observation
An unknown solid does not conduct electricity at room temperature. Two proposed models are an ionic crystal with immobile ions and a neutral molecular crystal. Assume the material can be melted without decomposing.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Name a measurement that can help distinguish the models and give each expected result.
Explain why one result should still be interpreted alongside composition or structural evidence.
Question 10 - Solution
Design a discriminating follow-up observation
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Measure conductivity of the melt: mobile ions would normally make the ionic melt conducting, whereas a melt of neutral molecules would ordinarily remain poorly conducting.
(b) Analysis
Chemical reactions, impurities, partial ionization and measurement sensitivity can complicate a single test. Composition and structure provide independent checks, so a proposed bonding model should explain a coherent set of observations.
Check and interpretation
This is an evidence-design problem; the stated no-decomposition assumption is essential.