Lewis Structures — Question 5

Section 8-10 · Chemistry pages 1475–1476

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Let the octet constrain an anion before judging charge location

Use formal charge FC=V−N−B/2FC=V-N-B/2, where V is neutral-atom valence count, N is nonbonding electrons and B is bonding electrons. For CN−^- use C = 4 and N = 5. Require octets on both atoms.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Construct a ten-electron Lewis structure and assign the lone pairs.

  2. Calculate both formal charges and explain why putting every negative formal charge on the more electronegative atom is not an absolute rule.

Question 5 - Solution

Let the octet constrain an anion before judging charge location

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The count is 4+5+1=104+5+1=10. A C≡\equivN triple bond uses six electrons; one lone pair on each atom uses the remaining four, giving both octets.

(b) Analysis

FCC=4−2−6/2=−1FC_C=4-2-6/2=-1 and FCN=5−2−6/2=0FC_N=5-2-6/2=0. This octet structure places the negative formal charge on C. Electronegativity is a preference among otherwise suitable alternatives, not permission to violate electron count or shell constraints.

Check and interpretation

The formal charges sum to the specified -1.