Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Show why a molecular formula need not fix connectivity
CHO has twenty valence electrons using C = 4, H = 1 and O = 6. Assume ordinary neutral valences: C four bonds, O two bonds, H one bond.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Give two different connected structures satisfying the formula and these valences.
For each, count bonding pairs and oxygen lone pairs, and explain why they are different structures rather than rotated drawings.
Question 7 - Solution
Show why a molecular formula need not fix connectivity
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The two familiar connectivities are ethanol, CH–CH–O–H, and dimethyl ether, CH–O–CH. Both have the stated formula.
(b) Analysis
Each has eight single bonds and two O lone pairs, using electrons. In ethanol O has a hydrogen neighbor and the carbons are adjacent; in ether O lies between the carbons. Rotation cannot change those neighbor relationships.
Check and interpretation
Electron count is necessary but does not uniquely determine the molecular graph.