Lewis Structures — Question 10

Section 8-10 · Chemistry pages 1485–1486

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Compare two octet structures with formal charges

Use formal charge FC=V−N−B/2FC=V-N-B/2, where V is neutral-atom valence count, N is nonbonding electrons and B is bonding electrons. For N2_2O with fixed N–N–O connectivity, consider A: N≡\equivN–O, with one lone pair on terminal N and three on O; B: N=N=O, with two lone pairs on terminal N and two on O. Central N has none in either. Use N = 5 and O = 6.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Verify both sixteen-electron inventories and calculate formal charges from left to right.

  2. Using the preference for negative formal charge on the more electronegative O rather than N, identify the favored contributor.

Question 10 - Solution

Compare two octet structures with formal charges

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

A has eight bonding and eight nonbonding electrons; its charges are (0,+1,−1)(0,+1,-1). B also has eight bonding and eight nonbonding electrons; its charges are (−1,+1,0)(-1,+1,0). Both satisfy octets and net neutrality.

(b) Analysis

A is favored by the supplied charge-placement criterion because it places the negative charge on O. This is a contributor-ranking rule, not a claim that the molecule has a fixed observable integer charge on each atom.

Check and interpretation

Both candidates must pass the electron and octet checks before applying the preference.