Resonance — Question 4

Section 8-12 · Chemistry pages 1513–1514

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Choose an arrow that matches the chemical claim

A writer uses the same symbol for (i) two contributors of one delocalized species and (ii) two distinct chemical species in dynamic equilibrium.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Give the standard resonance arrow and equilibrium-arrow notation and explain their different meanings.

  2. Why is the statement that resonance contributors rapidly interconvert misleading?

Question 4 - Solution

Choose an arrow that matches the chemical claim

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

A double-headed resonance arrow ↔\leftrightarrow connects contributors of one species; opposing equilibrium arrows ⇌\rightleftharpoons connect distinct species in a reversible process.

(b) Analysis

Contributors are alternative components of a description, not individually occupied molecular states between which the molecule must hop. Rapid interconversion language incorrectly introduces a kinetic process and separate populations.

Check and interpretation

The arrow is a statement about the model, not merely a typographical decoration.