Molecular Structure: The VSEPR Model — Question 9

Section 8-13 · Chemistry pages 1543–1544

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Use a supplied geometry to distinguish cis and trans dipoles

For a supplied square-planar AX2_2Y2_2 model, each outward A–X bond contribution is 1.0 D and each outward A–Y contribution is 0.4 D. In trans, identical ligands are opposite; in cis they are adjacent.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the trans resultant.

  2. For cis with X at +x and +y, find the resultant components, magnitude and direction.

Question 9 - Solution

Use a supplied geometry to distinguish cis and trans dipoles

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

In trans, the two X contributions cancel each other and so do the two Y contributions, giving zero.

(b) Analysis

For the specified cis arrangement, x and y components are each 1.0−0.4=0.61.0-0.4=0.6 D. The magnitude is 0.62+0.62=0.849\sqrt{0.6^2+0.6^2}=0.849 D, along the +x/+y bisector toward the X side.

Check and interpretation

Shape plus ligand placement and bond magnitudes are needed; the formula alone does not fix the dipole.