Electronegativity — Question 6

Section 8-2 · Chemistry pages 1317–1318

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Decide whether uncertain data support a polarity ranking

Hypothetical scale intervals are χA=2.0±0.1\chi_A=2.0\pm0.1, χB=3.0±0.1\chi_B=3.0\pm0.1 and χC=3.1±0.1\chi_C=3.1\pm0.1. Treat these as independent hard bounds. Compare A–B and A–C.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find allowed intervals for the two positive electronegativity differences.

  2. Does the information prove that A–C is more polar in every allowed case?

Question 6 - Solution

Decide whether uncertain data support a polarity ranking

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

For A–B the interval is [2.9−2.1,3.1−1.9]=[0.8,1.2][2.9-2.1,3.1-1.9]=[0.8,1.2]. For A–C it is [3.0−2.1,3.2−1.9]=[0.9,1.3][3.0-2.1,3.2-1.9]=[0.9,1.3].

(b) Analysis

No. The intervals overlap, and B can be 3.1 while C is 3.0, making A–B larger for the same A. Central values suggest A–C, but the uncertainty does not establish a universal ordering.

Check and interpretation

The common A value must be the same when comparing both bonds in one allowed scenario.