Bond Polarity and Dipole Moments — Question 2

Section 8-3 · Chemistry pages 1329–1330

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Compare two competing changes in a dipole model

Diatomic A has effective charge separation q over length r. Diatomic B has 0.80q over 1.50r. Both are neutral two-charge models.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find μB/μA\mu_B/\mu_A.

  2. Explain why the larger dipole need not mean a larger separated charge.

Question 2 - Solution

Compare two competing changes in a dipole model

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The ratio is (0.80q)(1.50r)/(qr)=1.20(0.80q)(1.50r)/(qr)=1.20. B has a 20% larger model dipole.

(b) Analysis

Dipole depends on both charge and separation. Here the smaller charge is outweighed by the longer distance. Comparing dipoles alone cannot isolate either variable unless the other is known.

Check and interpretation

The dimensionless ratio cancels the common units.