Show solutionHide solution
Question 6
Compare radius data only after matching definitions
A hypothetical ion X is listed as 74 pm in coordination number six and 82 pm in coordination number eight. Ion Y is listed as 78 pm in coordination number six. Assume the same ionic-radius convention within each coordination.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Which direct comparison of X and Y is supported?
Why does using 82 pm for X and 78 pm for Y not isolate an intrinsic element-only size ordering?
Question 6 - Solution
Compare radius data only after matching definitions
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
At coordination six, X is smaller than Y: 74 versus 78 pm.
(b) Analysis
The mixed comparison changes coordination as well as species. An assigned ionic radius depends on the surrounding structure and partition convention; these data do not separate a species effect from an environment effect.
Check and interpretation
A table entry is a conditional structural parameter, not a rigid universal sphere.