Formation of Binary Ionic Compounds — Question 5

Section 8-5 · Chemistry pages 1375–1376

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Compare lattice attraction with controlled assumptions

For two hypothetical salts of the same structure, assume lattice attraction magnitude scales as |z+z−|/r0|z_+z_-|/r_0. Salt P has charges +1/-1 and distance 250 pm; Q has +2/-2 and distance 200 pm. All other factors are held equal.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the predicted magnitude ratio Q/P.

  2. Why should this ratio not be used as an exact value for arbitrary real crystals?

Question 5 - Solution

Compare lattice attraction with controlled assumptions

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The ratio is (4/200)/(1/250)=5.0(4/200)/(1/250)=5.0. Q has five times the attraction magnitude in this controlled model.

(b) Analysis

Real structures differ in coordination, lattice sums, short-range repulsion and polarization. These factors need not cancel. The estimate isolates charge product and distance, not the complete crystal energy.

Check and interpretation

Larger charge products and smaller distances strengthen this model attraction.