Formation of Binary Ionic Compounds — Question 10

Section 8-5 · Chemistry pages 1385–1386

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Decide what an uncertain cycle really establishes

A hypothetical salt has total preparation enthalpy +600±30+600\pm30 kJ/mol and lattice formation enthalpy −650±40-650\pm40 kJ/mol, treated as independent hard bounds.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the central formation estimate and its full allowed interval.

  2. Can these data prove exothermic formation, and would negative enthalpy alone prove spontaneity under every condition?

Question 10 - Solution

Decide what an uncertain cycle really establishes

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The central value is -50 kJ/mol. Bounds are 570−690=−120570-690=-120 and 630−610=+20630-610=+20 kJ/mol, so the interval is [-120,+20].

(b) Analysis

The interval crosses zero, so exothermicity is not established for every allowed input. Even a definite negative enthalpy is not a universal spontaneity criterion: entropy, temperature and the complete thermodynamic process also matter.

Check and interpretation

Use interval endpoints consistently; do not report the central sign as certainty.